Skip to main content
Update Required: We noticed you are using an older version of Internet Explorer. To ensure full functionality of this site, please contact your system administrator to upgrade to the newest version of Internet Explorer or try accessing the site in Chrome.
HIROC
  • Home
  • Services
    • Risk Management
      Learn how our risk management solutions help you increase safety
    • Insurance
      Learn about our coverage offerings and how the HIROC advantage can work for you
    • Claims
      Learn about the claims process and the support HIROC provides
  • Resources
  • News & Events
    • Annual Conference
      Learn how the HIROC Annual Conference brings Subscribers, partners, and healthcare professionals together to drive patient safety forward
    • News
      News from HIROC and our subscribers about what’s trending in healthcare
    • Podcasts
      Podcasts from HIROC about healthcare
      • Healthcare Change Makers Podcast
      • Share Scale Repeat Podcast
    • Webinars and Events
      View our schedule of upcoming webinars and access the archives
  • About Us
    • Board of Directors
      Learn about our Board – made up of HIROC subscribers – and access the current list of Directors
    • Leadership Team
      A message from HIROC's CEO, Catherine Gaulton
    • Careers
      Want to join a team of innovators and leaders? Check out our current opportunities
    • Our Story, Our Art of Safety Strategy
      How HIROC and its Subscribers are working to create the safest healthcare system
    • Risk Management Residency Program (RMRP)
      Learn about the RMRP
    • Safety Grants Program
      Learn about the HIROC Foundation and the Safety Grants Program
  • Contact Us
Log in Register
HIROC
Log in Register
  1. Home
  2. Resources
  3. Retained Foreign Items

Related Resources

Risk Watch (October '25)

Download PDF

Members Only

Webinars

Documentation: Answers to Frequently Asked Questions

Care

Risk Case Studies

Patient/Client Falls

Download PDF

Retained Foreign Items

Category
Care
Topic
Adverse Events
Type
Risk Reference Sheets
  • LinkedIn

Retained foreign items include any tools or materials used in surgical and invasive procedures that are unintentionally left inside a client. Retained items can cause significant harm to clients, the source of which may only be determined months or years later. These occurrences often result in claims being brought against healthcare organizations, their employees and independent contractors. Such incidents are generally considered to be preventable and are therefore difficult to defend. In 2015, unintentional retained foreign item was recognized as one of Canada’s “never events” (defined as “patient safety incidents that result in serious patient harm or death that are preventable using organizational checks and balances” (Canadian Patient Safety Institute & Health Quality Ontario, 2015)). These incidents are frequently caused by counting errors that arise from organization, environmental and team factors. Developing and implementing effective count processes and maintaining a culture of shared accountability for the prevention of retained foreign items are key to managing this risk. 

Expected Outcomes

Adopt standardized current evidence-based surgical count and incident response protocols.

Implement formal strategies to support and enhance:
o        Effective communication of postoperative orders;
o        Retention of count sheets / records as a permanent part of the health record;
o        Safety culture in the work environment.

Adopt current best practice quality indicators for surgical / procedure counts processes.


Common Claims Themes and Contributing Factors 

Organizational
  • Inadequate count protocols for:
    • Surgery;
    • Additional instruments / sponges added to procedure;
    • Vaginal birth, assisted vaginal birth, and perineal trauma repair.
  • Perceived or actual systematic tolerance of unprofessional and unsafe behaviours as well as steep hierarchical culture in the perioperative and perinatal care settings,
Knowledge and Judgement  
  • Lack of compliance with policies and procedures related to surgical, birth, or perineal trauma repair counts.
  • Counts not performed for laparoscopic and minimally invasive procedures including vaginal births and perineal repairs.
  • Inadequate follow-up for items intentionally left in to be removed at a later time.
  • Use of abbreviated counts and counting short cuts (e.g., counting folded corners).
Communication 
  • Inadequate client handovers (relief and shift change).
  • Distractions or disruptions during counts.
  • Poor visualization or blocked view of the surgical site.
  • Unanticipated changes to the operative procedure resulting in changes to surgical items not being accounted for.
Documentation
  • Pre-emptive and falsification of documentation related to counts. 
  • Inconsistent documentation practices surrounding counts.

Mitigation Strategies

Count Processes

  • Adopt a standardized current evidence-based surgical count protocol, that includes (but not limited to) counting practice expectations for:
    • Invasive procedures;
    • Laparoscopic, endoscopic, and minimally invasive procedures;
    • Emergency procedures and abandoned counts;
    • Items added to the sterile filed after the initial count;
    • Births (vaginal, assisted vaginal births, and caesarean) and perineal suturing (i.e., hospital and community);
    • Packing intentionally left in to be removed later;
    • Two or more procedures done consecutively;
    • Incorrect counts (Operating Room Nurses Assocation of Canada, 2023) (Alberta Health Services, 2023) (ECRI, 2022) . 

Additional Considerations

Examples of elements to consider within the standardized evidence-based surgical count protocol:
  • Conducting counts for every surgical procedure (including cavity, non-cavity, and minimally invasive procedures) and for each caesarean and vaginal delivery;
  • Conducting counts at set-up and at defined times throughout a procedure including: before incision; before closure of a body cavity or wound; before a handoff during surgery; and before the client leaves the operating room or procedure area;
  • Limit distractions and interruptions during the count process;
  • Ensuring all standard and non-standard items are counted;
  • Prohibiting the use of non-radiopaque items and gauze smaller than 4x4cm in surgical sites whenever possible;
  • Separating sponges completely and view concurrently;
  • Conducting counts in a consistent, logical sequence (e.g., from largest to smallest);
  • Ensuring all counted items remain in the operating room or procedure area until a correct count is confirmed;
  • Ensure all instruments, supplies, and sharps are inspected upon removal from the surgical site to ensure they are intact.
  • Implement a standardized response protocol for when:
    • The final count is incorrect or if the initial count has not taken place;
    • A missing item cannot be seen on X-ray;
    • A previously retained item is encountered during a subsequent procedure.
  • Implement formal best practices strategies to minimize interruptions and distractions during surgical counts (Bubric, Biesbroek, Laberge, Martel, & Litvinchuk, 2021).

Safety Culture 

  • Implement formal strategies to develop and maintain a work environment which supports and expects:
    • Intra- and inter-professional collaboration and collegiality;
    • Zero tolerance of intra- and inter-disciplinary bullying and intimidation;
    • Assertive and respectful questioning and challenging of unsafe practices.
  • Adopt a standardized, formalized, and program-specific chain of command (escalation) protocol for the rapid escalation of unresolved care concerns or disagreements related orders, decisions, and / or unsafe practices.

Communication

  • Implement formal strategies to support the effective communication of postoperative orders with respect to wound packing intentionally left by the surgical team.

Documentation 

  • Implement strategies to support the retention of count sheets / records as a permanent part of the health record.

Additional Considerations

Examples of areas of improvement to consider when monitoring, measuring, and improving documentation related to counts:
  • Items or instruments added during surgery or birth;
  • The names, titles, and signatures of staff performing the counts;
  • Any technology used for counts and the results;
  • Surgeon or delivering practitioner notified, actions taken and results when there is a count discrepancy;
  • The rationale for not performing a count (e.g., emergency);
  • The number and type of intentionally retained items, and follow-up actions.

Monitoring and Measurement    

  • Adopt a standardized, interdisciplinary, collaborative, and evidence-based protocol for conducting quality of care reviews involving retained foreign items resulting in client harm or death (Incident Analysis Collaborating Parties, 2012) (Machen, 2023); incorporate system thinking and human factors concepts into the review process.
  • Adopt standardized quality indicators for surgical / procedure counts processes.
  • Incorporate learning from local, provincial, and national retained foreign item safety reviews and data into local protocols as well as staff and client education and training.

References
  • Alberta Health Services. (2023, 2). Surgical Count. Retrieved May 13, 2023, from Alberta Health Services: https://extranet.ahsnet.ca/teams/policydocuments/1/clp-prov-sugical-count-ps-109.pdf
  • Bubric, K. A., Biesbroek, S. L., Laberge, J. C., Martel, J. A., & Litvinchuk, S. D. (2021). Prevalence and characteristics of interruptoins and distractions during surgical counts. The Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety, 47(9), 556-562. doi:doi.org/10.1016/j.jcjq.2021.05.004
  • Canadian Patient Safety Institute & Health Quality Ontario. (2015). Never Events for Hospital Care in Canada. 
  • ECRI. (2022, 7). Unintentionally Retained Surgical Items. Retrieved from ECRI: https://www.ecri.org/components/HRC/Pages/UnintentionallyRetainedSurgicalItems.aspx
  • Incident Analysis Collaborating Parties. (2012). Canadian Incident Analysis Framework. Edmonton, AB.
  • Machen, S. (2023, 5). Thematic reviews of patient safety incidents as a tool for systems thinking: a quality improvement report. BMJ Open Quality, 12(2), e002020.
  • Operating Room Nurses Assocation of Canada. (2023, 4). The ORNAC Standards, Guidelines, and Position Statement for Perioperative Registered Nurses. Retrieved from ORNAC: http://www.ornac.ca/en/standards



 

   


 

 

Date last reviewed: July 2023
This is a resource for quality assurance and risk management purposes and should not be taken as legal or medical advice. Nothing in this document articulates or proposes a standard of care or required practice. Rather, our goal is to share empirical information for the guidance of healthcare organizations and practitioners regarding risk and quality issues. The information contained in this resource was considered accurate at the time of publication, however, practices may change without notice. Please direct questions related to the currency of the information or its application to your specific circumstances to [email protected].

Related Resources

Risk Watch (October '25)

Download PDF

Members Only

Webinars

Documentation: Answers to Frequently Asked Questions

Care

Risk Case Studies

Patient/Client Falls

Download PDF

Partnering to create the safest healthcare system

HIROC is not just a not-for-profit, we are a reciprocal. This means we are governed by our Subscribers – a group of over 800 diverse healthcare organizations across Canada. Together we share learnings and find ways to adapt to the changing nature of the industry.
Learn More
HIROC staff members
HIROC
Join our newsletter to stay up to date with the latest news.
By subscribing you agree with our Privacy Policy and provide consent to receive updates from HIROC.

About Us

  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Our Story, Our Art of Safety Strategy
  • Risk Management Residency Program (RMRP)
  • Safety Grants Program

Quicklinks

  • Claims
  • Insurance
  • Risk Management

Important information

  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • AODA

©2026 HIROC All rights reserved.

  • Linkedin
  • Instagram
  • Youtube